The Great American Read: what can we learn from the final ranking of books?



The Great American Read on PBS has come to a close and the books have been ranked. The top 10 most-beloved books are:

10. “Jane Eyre” by Charlotte Bronte

9. “The Chronicles of Narnia” series by C.S. Lewis

8. “Little Women” by Louisa May Alcott

7. “Charlotte’s Web” by E.B. White

6. “Gone with the Wind” by Margaret Mitchell

5. The Lord of the Rings series by J.R.R. Tolkien

4. “Pride and Prejudice” by Jane Austen

3. The Harry Potter series by J.K. Rowling

2. The Outlander series by Diana Gabaldon

1. “To Kill a Mockingbird” by Harper Lee

This is an excellent top-10 of books, and I think we can learn a lot about the reading community if we look closely at it.

Out of the top 10, seven books are ones readers would have a good chance of being introduced to at a young age, in their most formative years. Think back to the books that really stood out when you were younger, whether you read them alone, in a classroom or with an adult. Odds are good that you carry them with you still. I remember an elementary school teacher reading the whole class both “Charlotte’s Web” and “The Hobbit” when I was a student, and the joy when it was reading time — all of us gathered around on the floor listening intently as the stories unfolded, groaning when it was time for her to stop (she was excellent at knowing where to stop for the most effect to keep us excited.) There are a number of studies that impress upon us the importance of starting your children young with books; this ranking supports that information — as well as showing us the importance of reading great literature in school.


Out of the top ten, seven authors are female. There is a huge movement in the literary community at the moment for readers to make a conscious effort to read more books by women, and this ranking shows the importance of literary work by women.

We can clearly see that a visual representation of the books is important; all of the top 10 have been made into either movies or television series. I’m quite sure Gabaldon’s Outlander series would not be in the top 10 if the show wasn’t currently such a hit for Starz, as the books in the series aren’t something to be quickly skimmed — one of the later books in the series (which, yes, I have read) is almost 1,500 pages long. I know there’s a lot of worry when a beloved book is transferred to the screen, be it the big or small one, but if it puts the book in the public eye, there’s always a chance the viewer will find the book itself and read it — and anything that gets people reading works for me.

Readers like books with staying power, it seems — only two of the top ten are truly contemporary titles. And readers like books with hope and love in them; every one of these books I would consider a hopeful read, filled with strong, relatable characters and lots of love.

The books I was most worried about ranking highly didn’t do well at all — sorry, “Twilight,” (No. 73) “Fifty Shades of Gray” (No. 86) and “Flowers in the Attic” (No. 85) — and this gives me hope that people want good, well-written books more than they want titillating flash-in-the-pan fiction written so luridly and poorly that it could be a study in what not to do in a writing workshop.

And “To Kill a Mockingbird” at the No. 1 spot is a wonderful choice. It’s a book with something for everyone, that teaches lessons about social problems, compassion and love, and its themes are as important today as they were when it was written. I can only hope that people who may not have read the book pick it up now that it’s in the news; it’s a book that absolutely everyone should read, and I stand behind this choice completely.

Overall, this project was a fine choice on PBS’s part. People got excited about books — reading them, talking about them, thinking about them, voting for them. The series that ran while the voting went on was a fun watch and brought book-lovers together in a joyful way. Books are one of the most important things in my life, and seeing others celebrate that has been so fulfilling for me — and it’s wonderful to know others feel the same way.